AMY VIOLETTE IS WEARING ALL BLACK, from her boots to her cowboy hat. Her long, blond hair hangs loose down her back. As we shake hands in greeting, a man nearby teases her about looking like Johnny Cash, making her blush. Though she has a southern drawl and could fairly be described as a “horse girl,” she also happens to be an up-and-coming handbag designer, an actress, a producer, a screenwriter, a seasoned horseback rider, and an ordained Baptist minister. But more than once she explains, I’m just Amy. — JL
From your website, you seem like a sort of Jill of All Trades. Do you have an elevator pitch that encompasses everything you are?
No. I’m a religious person, a spiritual person. I was first called as a pastor. One of the through-lines for me has been words and story. When I was in college I wrote songs. In seminary, I wrote sermons. Now, I write for TV and film. Maybe, at first glance, I might seem a little all-over-the-place, but people who sit and get to know me — it’s just Amy.
Authenticity is something I hope comes through in everything I do, whether that’s the bags or TV and film. I just got off an Apple TV movie last year, and they brought me back, which was great.
What’s the movie?
It’s called The Lost Bus with Mathew McConaughey and America Ferrera. We wrapped it last year. I got hired to come on for a few days, and then they brought me back to do asset management. I managed a $150 million budget for buses, wardrobe — everything that gets inventoried. And then at the end, I decide with Apple executives whether we sell it or keep it.
You are also a pastor. How did that happen?
Frederick Buechner has this quote: You’re in the right vocation where your deep gladness and the world’s deep hunger meet. What is that thing you want to do that the world needs? For me, it’s bringing people hope and helping connect people. But Southern Baptists don’t think women can be preachers. It’s in the Baptist faith and message — they don’t believe it’s biblical for women to teach men.
What gave you the confidence to think you could do it anyway?
Because I was good at it. I felt like I was a good teacher. I love teaching people, and I think I like teaching the Bible. I got to do an Easter service at Bishop’s Lodge a couple of months ago, and there’s something so comfortable for me in that. But I want to do more than just teach the gospel.
The word pastor — I have a hard time with that. I don’t think I’m superior to anybody. All we can do is share my life, share your story, and we’ll get through this thing together. I’m not trying to convert you or manipulate you.
I grew up Southern Baptist, then went to school to be a Baptist. They believe women can preach, but they’ll never set you up in a church to get a job. So I’m a woman who feels called to preach. I love the idea that preaching and acting are similar.
I had a hard childhood. My dad is verbally abusive and has PTSD from Vietnam. I grew up without a voice. Being able to get on stage — that’s how I feel seen. This person inside me gets to come out.
Do you think you would have been able to teach the way you do if you hadn’t had that traumatic experience?
Absolutely not. I’m better now because I understand the world in a different way. We’re all just trying to lead each other home a little bit. I have a lot of empathy. When somebody reads me as entitled or privileged, I’m like, I’m the furthest from that ever. I’ve had so many failures.
I think there’s a grit to me, a drive to continue, because I am a hopeful person. I do believe in God — and that can look a lot of different ways. I don’t need you to think of God the same way I think of God. God is in the trees, in the mountains. I love living in a place where I see so much beauty every day.
I was with these Benedictine monks who called me the cowgirl. Every spring break I would go back and stay with them. They said if I came and stayed for a week or two for free in the guest house, I had to come to one prayer a day. I would go to the shortest prayer right before lunch — 15 minutes. I’d wear my chaps, and I realized these people are normal humans too.
How did the handbags come about?
I saved up $300 and went to Dillard’s and bought a Coach bag. Within two weeks, the straps broke. Then I was carrying this ratty canvas tote bag from Barnes & Noble for my books. I was carrying these two broken bags up the stairs to school every day, and I started crying on the stairs one day. I was like, This is my life — everything is broken. That night I went home, got a piece of notebook paper, and designed a bag. I took it to my leather guy because I’d had horses, and he was literally the leather guy next to my barn. I said, Can you make this? He said yes.
For an entire year, I just carried my bag, and people would stop me and say, I love your bag. Then, I was coming back from having an extra role on Godless, this Netflix western, and I was at the Santa Fe airport. A flight attendant named Sherry said, I love your bag. I said, Well, let me make you one. That was the first sale. Sherry has them in every color now. She gave me a couple hundred dollars cash right there.
The bags changed my life. It grew one woman at a time. I’m not a purse person. I’m a worker bee. I’m somebody who has a work bag, and that’s what these are — leather work bags.
You auditioned for Juilliard?
Two years ago for acting. I didn’t get in, but it’s one of the best things I’ve ever done. Three years ago, I got to be in Santa Fe Opera’s Carmen. That happened through a guy I used to work with at camp when I was 18 — he books all the talent for Santa Fe Opera. He asked me to play Manuelita, Carmen’s boss at the cigarette factory. I was, for ten performances with Isabel Leonard, a Grammy Award-winning opera singer. It was one of the most fun things I’ve ever done. Around that time, I watched Thelma and Louise for the first time.
For the first time? That’s my favorite movie.
You get what you settle for. That spoke to me so deeply. I was like, I’m not done yet. What’s the wildest, scariest thing I can imagine? I said, Apply to Juilliard.
Do you feel like you’ve found a spiritual place in Santa Fe?
It’s changing. It used to be the monastery in Abiquiu. But I think there’s an evolution. I got to go to the Buffalo dances last year. I think they’re tapped into something powerful — the way they honor the directions and the stars.
In New Mexico, if you grew up here or if you’re here, we’re so influenced by the Native American — whether we get it or not — it’s the sky and the stars and the directions and the spiritual. But Christianity really hurt them. They built the churches on top of them. So I grew up in total fear of the church. I saw a cross and it terrified me.
But I love reading the Bible because there’s clues everywhere in it. As Taylor Swift says, there’s Easter eggs everywhere. And if you don’t read it, you’re going to miss it. But reading it is doing something, and I think it is inspiring.
I’ve always said that I’m a follower of Jesus, and that means a very specific thing. Once you read about the life of Jesus, who he was, who he hung out with — the message was inclusion, people, and hope. The message was love. Sermon on the Mount is all about taking care of the poor.
What about coming out? How did that happen?
After my divorce, I dated guys again because that’s what I’m supposed to do, right? Then there was this woman — she was a bartender and a PhD student at Baylor. She would come over to my house after work, and we’d drink wine. I would have candles lit, and I would give her massages. I thought she was so pretty, but I just didn’t know how to do anything.
Then one day we were on my porch and she was laying in my lap and I was playing with her hair, and I just leaned down like Spider-Man and kissed her. I didn’t know if she was giving me vibes, but she looked at me and then kissed me back. I knew in that moment, Oh, shit.
I’ve dated a lot of different types of people and it’s been fun. I want to meet a partner that is an equal. Maybe we can co-create something really beautiful together. But I’m not willing to settle.
Coming to New Mexico, I needed to sit with myself. Coming from the upbringing that I came from, I was like, Is this even okay? Can I be a pastor and can I be gay? I dated a woman that was a pastor one time and she was very rainbow hair, rainbow flags, every sermon’s about being gay. I was like, That’s just not me. It’s one one-thousandth of who I am. It’s not scary to me anymore to come out as gay. It’s more scary to come out as a pastor.
You own a horse.
I had one horse, and then I got another horse, and they had a baby. I keep them all in Cerrillos. They’re my heart. My horse came to me in a dream last night. I had a traumatic horse accident when I was 12, and almost died. I saw myself looking down at my body. I told God if He got me out of it, I’d serve Him the rest of my life.
What happened?
I was training dressage. My horse was three years old, and they put side reigns on him, which you should never do. We’d been at it for two hours and we should’ve stopped. He couldn’t move his head, and he reared up and I held on, but the reigns were so tight that he couldn’t put his head back around to balance. He started falling backwards, and I fell, so he fell on top of me and rolled over. My lungs collapsed. It was a miracle I made it.
You have a kind of innate confidence that life will work out. Where does that come from?
Good question. Thank you for asking. This is going to sound a little woo-woo. Because I’ve had these near-death experiences, I think every day is a gift. I don’t expect a next one. I’m so fortunate to have every day, so I live it like it could be the last. I’ve always been an optimistic person. If I’m going to err, I’m going to err on the side of hope and encouragement. There’s so much negativity in the world. If I latch on to that, then what’s the point? It’s bigger than me. There’s something bigger out there that I’ve always been tapped into. I would call it God, and it doesn’t have to look like Jesus-in-the-Bible God.
And New Mexico has helped heal me. Everyone who comes here is running, hiding, or healing. That’s who we all are. We’re all healing. That’s beautiful to me. I just don’t think I could have stayed where I was and been defined by one thing that happened to me. We’re not just one thing that happened to us.